The wettability of the reservoir has gained a lot of interest since it is recognized as one of the key factors affecting enhanced oil recovery. In carbonate reservoirs, wettability alteration is the main mechanism for enhanced oil recovery. The wettability studies are used to determine the original wettability state of the reservoir as well as to study the effect of different enhanced oil recovery strategies. Most commonly used quantitative methods to study reservoir wettability are Amott-Harvey, USBM (US Bureau of Mines), and sessile drop contact angle.
The Amott-Harvey method uses a combination of spontaneous and forced imbibition measurements of initially oil saturated cores. Displacement of both water by oil as well as oil by water is tested. The data is used to calculate the displacement by oil index which is a ratio between water volume displaced by spontaneous oil imbibition alone and the total volume displaced by oil imbibition and forced displacement.
Prior to measurements, the preparation of the core sample is done so that it is in irreducible water saturation, i.e. at the lowest water saturation possible to achieve. In the first measurement step the core is placed into the water-filled tube and the spontaneous imbibition of water over a period of time, at least 10 days, is measured. Then, the core is placed in a flow cell and water is forced through the sample. The additional oil recovery is recorded. Now the sample is in residual oil saturation point meaning the state where, as much oil is recovered as possible with water. Next, the process is repeated so that the spontaneous imbibition of oil is measured followed by the forced flow.
The result is the Amott-Harvey index which is a difference between the water and oil ratios and varies from + 1 (strongly water-wet) to – 1 (strongly oil-wet).
The USBM test was developed by Donaldson in 1969. As Amott – Harvey test, it measures the average wettability of the core. The USBM test compares the amount of work required to replace one fluid with the other. The method is based on forced imbibition of fluid inside the core which is achieved by centrifuge spins with stepwise-increasing speed.
As The Amott-Harvey methods, The USBM starts with the irreducible water saturated core inside a water-filled tube. After periods at several spin rates, the sample reaches residual oil saturation, and it is placed in an oil-filled tube for other series of measurements. The produced curve is similar to Amott-Harvey, but now the areas between each of the capillary-pressure curves and the zero capillary -pressure line are calculated. The logarithm of the ratio of the water -increasing to oil-increasing areas give the USBM wettability index. The practical measurement results are typically in a range of +1 (strongly water-wet) to + 1 (strongly oil – wet). The USMB method is faster than Amott-Harvey since the spontaneous imbibition is not done but must be corrected because the centrifuge induces a nonlinear capillary-pressure gradient in the sample.
Contact angle (sessile drop)
The sessile drop contact angle measurements offer a simple method to study reservoir wettability. One of the advantages of the method is also that it can be conducted at elevated temperatures and high pressures which mimics the reservoir conditions. It can also be used to study the effect of other experimental conditions such as brine chemistry on wettability.
In practice, a drop of liquid, typically crude oil, is placed on a core sample surrounded by brine. As contact angle is commonly presented as a drop of heavier liquid in lighter phase (eq. water in air or water in oil), the contact angle ranges for water-wet, intermediate – wet and oil – wet are as presented in figure below.
To hear how contact angle measurements have been used to study the liberation of unconventional oil, watch the webinar by Prof. Xu.
Different enhanced oil recovery methods are used to alter the wettability of the reservoir rock. To study the wettability alteration at the reservoir conditions, an instrument where the measurements can be done at high pressures and temperatures are needed.
Unconventional oils, such as heavy oil, extra heavy oil, and bitumen, normally exist tightly on host solids such as rocks, sands and clay minerals. Successful liberation of unconventional oil from solids is essential for effective recovery.
In enhanced oil recovery wettability plays an important role as that determines the interactions between the solid (rock) and the liquids in the reservoirs (crude oil, brine). Wettability has been recognized as one of the key parameters controlling the remaining oil-in-place.